Why Brad Marchand Should Be a Hart Trophy Candidate

by | Mar 19, 2017 | Soapbox | 12 comments

Boston Bruins winger Brad Marchand is garnering praise for his outstanding play this season.

The recent scoring surge by Boston Bruins left wing Brad Marchand has him challenging for the lead in this season’s NHL goals and points race. That’s also generated some talk suggesting the 28-year-old could be a candidate for the Hart Memorial Trophy as the most valuable player to his team.

Until a couple of months ago, Marchand as a Hart Trophy candidate would’ve seem a far-fetched notion. It took his recent rise in the scoring race to get some pundits to take notice of his play.

As of March 18, Marchand led the Bruins in goals (37), assists (42) and points (79). He also led them in shorthanded points (five) and shooting percentage (17.8) and was tied with Patrice Bergeron for the lead in game-winning goals (seven).

Marchand’s also in a three-way tie with David Pastrnak and Torey Krug for the team lead in power-play points (21) and with Dominic Moore for the lead in shorthanded goals (three). He’s second in power-play goals (eight) and third in shots (208).

The recent surge in the scoring race by Marchand shouldn’t be surprising. He’s been among the league leaders in goals and points for most of this season, putting him in position to challenge for the Art Ross Trophy as the league’s leading scorer and the Richard Trophy as the top goal scorer.

In recent days, columnists from The Boston Globe, Boston Herald, CSNNE.com and NESN made the case for Marchand to receive consideration for the Hart Trophy. While unsurprising that Boston-area columnists would sing his praises, they were also joined by TSN’s Bob McKenzie and Frank Seravalli, The Hockey News’ Jared Clinton and Puck Daddy’s Greg Wyshynski.

Despite Marchand’s impressive numbers, most observers acknowledge he faces an uphill battle for the Hart. He’ll be going up against Pittsburgh Penguins captain and two-time Hart winner Sidney Crosby, as well as Crosby’s teammate and former Hart winner Evgeni Malkin, Chicago Blackhawks right wing (and 2016 Hart winner) Patrick Kane, young Edmonton Oilers captain Connor McDavid and San Jose Sharks’ defenseman Brent Burns.

Marchand’s reputation as a dirty player could also hurt his chances. On January 26, he received a $10,000 fine for what the NHL Department of Player Safety labelled a dangerous trip on Detroit Red Wings defenseman Niklas Kronwall. Given his lengthy history of suspensions (four infractions totaling 12 games) and three previous fines in his NHL career, it’s surprising he didn’t miss more time.

Those prior transgressions could work against Marchand when the Professional Hockey Writers Association casts their votes for the Hart later this spring. Even if he goes on to win the Art Ross and Richard trophies, some pundits probably won’t bring themselves to vote for the Bruins’ pest.

NHL fans have no say in the voting. However, some will undoubtedly consider it a disgrace that a player with a checkered history such as Marchand should even merit consideration for the Hart.

Despite the competition and his reputation, few players were as valuable to his team this season as Marchand to the Bruins.

I made the case back on February 4, when I named Marchand as my dark-horse candidate for the Hart.

It’s been a roller coaster season for the Bruins. There were a couple of points where they teetered on the brink of falling out of playoff contention. They also underwent a mid-season coaching change. While holding a playoff berth today, only four points separates the Bruins from the ninth overall New York Islanders in the Eastern Conference. A late losing skid or a strong surge by the Isles and the eighth overall Toronto Maple Leafs could still knock them down the standings. 

Through it all, Marchand’s been their one constant this season. While Bergeron, David Krejci, David Backes and Ryan Spooner struggled at times offensively, he was consistently their leading scorer and best player by a wide margin. Without him, the Bruins probably wouldn’t be holding a postseason spot right now

Regardless of reputation, Marchand is worthy of serious consideration for the Hart Trophy.


  1. Rename it the turd trophy and he’s perfect for it.

    • Pithy comments aside – if he suddenly played for your team he’d be the greatest but misunderstood player in the game.

      • Not for me. I dont like the filth. Was glad Neal got traded for his shinanigans and even if the return was not as good as it was I woulda cheered. Last dirty player I cheered for was Ulfy and I was like 9. Malkin should have been suspended for the hit to Wheeler and the team shoulda been fined for bringing up sestitio. no place for that crap in the game. and it would be a sad day if marchand won the hart. reflects poorly on the league.

  2. Great read Lyle, I think your article is spot on. I also believe his pass transgressions will hurt is chances. With Tor, Ott, TB and NYI on the schedule this week for the Bruins, probably the most important week of the season and if Marchand and the bruins can pick up 3 out of 4 wins and Brad has a strong week it will be tough to keep Marchand out of the conversation. If no playoffs no hart.

  3. The award is for the player most valued to his team and without Marchy the Bruins would definitely be on the outside looking in. Past suspensions should have no bearing on this award.

    • Exactly. Ty Cobb was an all-time a”*hole and racist SOB to boot – but he won games for his team on the way to winning awards and World Series and is in the Hall of Fame.

      • Kind of a different era tho no? Cobb was inducted in to the Hall of Fame in 1930s lol I’m not sure it was out of the ordinary in the early 1900s for people from Georgia and the southern US to have similar views.

      • Pete rose in the Hall of Fame? No because he broke the rules.

      • Yes, but Rose will make it, eventually – probably within the next 5 years.

  4. Easily the best player the last six months he made Crosby and Bergie at World Cup and now he may be just God.

  5. Good article, Lyle. Way to go, Brad Marchand!

  6. Not a Marchand fan but no denying his stats or the space on the ice his style of play creates for others.Like him or not,the other 29, now 30 teams, would rather be playing with him than against him.


  1. And the Hart Trophy Goes To... - […] catalyst has been an unlikely one, super-pest Brad Marchand. For most of the season, he’s gained a reputation for…
  2. Granlund's surgery; USWNT negotiations; Giroux's hip issues (Puck Headlines) – My News Tech Viral Current News - […] • Why Brad Marchand should be this year’s MVP. [Spector’s Hockey] […]