NHL CBA Update – January 20, 2019

by | Jan 20, 2019 | Soapbox | 1 comment

In recent weeks, discussions between the NHL and NHL Players Association regarding a possible a World Cup of Hockey tournament in September 2020 prompted speculation the event could become a deadline for a new collective bargaining agreement.

NHL and NHLPA agree not to stage a World Cup of Hockey in 2020.

Both sides have the option to opt-out of the current agreement this September. It was assumed they would avoid the current CBA expiring while the tournament was taking place. 

Considering the contentious labor history between the two sides, the possibility of labor peace by September 2020 would be a welcome change.

Last week, however, the league and the PA released joint statements announcing it was “no longer realistic” to schedule that tournament next September.

Such news would ordinarily suggest more labor trouble on the horizon. However, most observers noted the tone of the statements was rather mild, with both two sides indicated their intention to continue broader discussions.

In other words, just because there won’t be a World Cup of Hockey next year doesn’t necessarily mean there won’t be a new CBA in the near future.

Since November, various reports have the league and the PA holding ongoing talks regarding a possible CBA extension.  NHL commissioner Gary Bettman seems keen to avoid a fourth lockout on his watch, recently telling reporters he’s not looking for a fight with the PA.

Fans can be forgiven for their cynicism over Bettman’s comment. As the good folks at the Puck Soup podcast observed, the commissioner said the same thing roughly a year before imposing the season-killing lockout of 2004-05. 

By most accounts, the league doesn’t have any significant issues worth jeopardizing a season over. Escrow and Olympic participation are hot-button topics for the players but the PA doesn’t sound as militant as it once was.

Some pundits have noted a distinct change in tone between the two sides, providing hope that a new collective bargaining agreement can be worked out without another long work stoppage. Time will tell if that’s the case. 

1 Comment

  1. I have no idea if this is real, but I have a suspicion that much of the labor difficulty between the players and management comes from the agents, and two facts. First, some agents, and the union head, have roots in other sports where there is a lot more money available. Second, for some reason the PA is skewed toward the stars, with a terrible deal for the rank and file (especially compared to the rich sports). I’m OK with trying to get as big a share of revenue as you can….the players are, to a degree, the game. But there is an explosion of young players, the cap playing a role. The fans might be better served with top producers making top money while they produce, and contracts diminishing with diminished performance. Dead money and “cap hell” are as much a product of a bad system as bad GMs. Paying a little more to a lot of productive young players under a structure and a little less to a few aging stars hurts the agents more than anyone, hence my suspicion.


  1. Dan’s Daily Links: Price for Zuccarello, Muzzin & CBA Update | Hockey Insider | NHL News, Drafts, Picks, Schedules & NHL Betting Online - […] A stick tap to our old friend–Spector’s Hockey. Lyle Richardson is one of those hardworking hockey writers who was…