NHL Rumor Mill – May 21, 2025

NHL Rumor Mill – May 21, 2025

Check out the latest on Mitch Marner and Nikolaj Ehlers, plus a look at the Golden Knights’ possible offseason plans in today’s NHL Rumor Mill.

THE LATEST MARNER SPECULATION

TSN: Pierre LeBrun noted the contrast between Toronto Maple Leafs forwards John Tavares and Mitch Marner when discussing their futures during Tuesday’s media availability.

Tavares was optimistic about returning with the Leafs next season. However, Marner spoke in the past tense about loving being a Leaf, and his intention to take time with his family to discuss his future.

Toronto Maple Leafs winger Mitch Marner (NHL Images).

Chris Johnston believes Marner intends to test the free-agent market on July 1. He noted that the 28-year-old winger didn’t want to discuss a contract during this season.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: Marner’s situation has reached the point of no return. He’s a goner to the highest bidder on July 1.

TORONTO SUN: Steve Simmons also believes it’s time for the Leafs and Marner to part ways. He believes the winger’s rights can be traded for next to nothing before July 1 or he leaves in free agency.

Simmons noted the Leafs will have around $22 million in cap space to work with if they don’t re-sign Marner and Tavares. He suggested using that money to get into the bidding for forward Sam Bennett if he doesn’t re-sign with the Florida Panthers before July 1. Simmons also noted that Panthers defenseman Aaron Ekblad could also be available.

Other free-agent options could include Nikolaj Ehlers of the Winnipeg Jets, Brock Boeser of the Vancouver Canucks, Patrick Kane of the Detroit Red Wings and the Panthers’ Brad Marchand.

DAILY FACEOFF: Frank Seravalli doesn’t rule out the possibility of the Leafs finding a trade destination for Marner where he wants to pre-negotiate before July 1.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: The Leafs won’t get a big return for Marner if they trade his rights before July 1. The Carolina Hurricanes got a 2025 third-round pick for Jake Guentzel when they traded his rights to the Tampa Bay Lightning last June.

WILL NIKOLAJ EHLERS STAY WITH THE JETS OR TEST THE MARKET?

THE ATHLETIC: Murat Ates looked at what the Winnipeg Jets must address during the offseason.

Sorting out their contract signings is a priority, with Nikolaj Ehlers being the biggest question mark. The 28-year-old winger is UFA-eligible on July 1 and might be inclined to test the market after 10 years in Winnipeg. He wasn’t available at the Jets’ media availability on Tuesday as he departed for the World Championships to play for his native Denmark.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: Ehlers’ teammates praised him during the media availability, expressing their hope that he’ll re-sign with the Jets. If he hits the open market, he won’t lack for suitors. The Province’s Ben Kuzma believes the Vancouver Canucks will be among the bidders.

UPDATE ON THE GOLDEN KNIGHTS

VEGAS HOCKEY NOW: Hannah Kirkell doesn’t expect Golden Knights management to blow up the roster after their elimination from the second round of the 2025 playoffs.

She acknowledged the Golden Knights’ inability to score against the Edmonton Oilers led to their elimination. Their shallow prospect pool means they don’t have many tradeable assets, meaning they’ll have to turn to free agency to bolster their offense.

The Golden Knights will have over $9.6 million in cap space next season. That’s not enough to add someone like Mitch Marner via free agency. Winnipeg’s Nikolaj Ehlers could be just out of their price range, and there will be plenty of suitors for Vancouver’s Brock Boeser.

General manager Kelly McCrimmon will have to get creative. Jack Eichel is the only untouchable on the Golden Knights’ roster. Five of their nine forwards and three of their five defensemen signed through next season have some form of no-trade protection.

Kirkell suggested winger Ivan Barbashev as a trade candidate because he only has an eight-team no-trade list. Their depth at center could allow them to dangle Nicolas Roy as trade bait for a scoring winger.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: McCrimmon and the Golden Knights’ front office have a reputation for making surprising moves to improve their roster. It won’t be shocking if they swing a major deal this summer to improve their offense.










NHL Rumor Mill – May 20, 2025

NHL Rumor Mill – May 20, 2025

The ongoing fallout from the Maple Leafs’ second-round elimination in today’s NHL Rumor Mill.

THE SCORE: John Matisz believes change is coming for the Toronto Maple Leafs, but he wonders how much.

Matisz doesn’t expect team president Brendan Shanahan or pending free-agent winger Mitch Marner will receive contract extensions. He doubts that general manager Brad Treliving or head coach Craig Berube will lose their jobs because they were hired within the last two years.

John Tavares is also due to become a free agent, but his situation isn’t so cut and dried. He could remain a Leaf if he accepts a significant pay cut and a reduced role. Meanwhile, restricted free-agent winger Matthews Knies must be signed sooner rather than later to avoid receiving an offer sheet from a rival club.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: That’s assuming Knies is open to signing an offer sheet. It could cost between $7.020 million and $9.36 million to sign him, meaning the Leafs would get a first, a second and a third-round pick in the 2026 draft as compensation. That combination could be too rich for most clubs. Remember, those draft picks have to belong to the team making the offer, it can’t be picks they acquired from another club.

Matisz thinks Treliving must acquire a top-six winger to replace Marner and perhaps a second-line center to replace Tavares. He must also address the club’s lack of production among its bottom-six forwards. They also need a middle-six puck-moving defenseman.

SPORTSNET: Justin Bourne believes the Maple Leafs should avoid signing Sam Bennett if the versatile Florida Panthers forward becomes a UFA on July 1. He’ll be 29 and seeking a seven-year contract that the Leafs could regret as his physical style begins to wear him down. Nikolaj Ehlers of the Winnipeg Jets might be a more affordable option and would replace some of Marner’s offense.

Toronto Maple Leafs defenseman Morgan Rielly (NHL Images).

Bourne isn’t sure that bringing back Tavares on a discount would be a good thing since he’s been part of the Leafs’ recent postseason failures. He also singled out the declining play of defenseman Morgan Rielly, who carries an average annual value of $7.5 million that might be better spent elsewhere.

DAILY FACEOFF: Matt Larkin also cited Rielly’s declining performance. He believes the Leafs’ offseason priority should be acquiring a puck-moving defenseman. Larkin noted the pickings are slim in this summer’s UFA market, and suggested checking into the trade market by kicking tires on a player like Noah Dobson of the New York Islanders.

If the Leafs are thinking short term, he suggested signing UFA forwards like Bennett and Florida teammate Brad Marchand.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: The 37-year-old Marchand would definitely be short-term as he’ll likely get a two or three-year contract. Bennett would help them in the first two or three years, but I agree with Bourne that his deal would become burdensome in its final years.

Frank Seravalli wondered if the Maple Leafs’ purge might end at Mitch Marner. He also mentioned Tavares and Rielly, and even asked, “What about Auston Matthews?”

SPECTOR’S NOTE: Matthews is in the first season of his four-year contract extension with full no-movement protection. However, we can’t dismiss the possibility that he might welcome a trade if the right opportunity presents itself.

TORONTO STAR: Kevin McGran looked at the Leafs’ options for the offseason. They could use the cap saving from letting Marner go to free agency to put toward signing Winnipeg’s Nikolaj Ehlers or winger Brock Boeser of the Vancouver Canucks. He also suggested waiting a year and trying to sign Connor McDavid when the Edmonton Oilers captain is UFA-eligible.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: McDavid won’t be available. The Oilers will sign him to an extension, making him the highest-paid player in the league.

McGran also mentioned Rielly’s deteriorating play and his $7.5 million AAV. He also has a no-movement clause, but McGran suggested the buyout route.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: Forget about the buyout. Rielly has five years left on his contract, meaning the buyout would be on their books for the next 10 years. The cap hit for the first year is $1.633 million, rising to $3.633 million annually for the next four years, before dropping to $2.133 million annually for the remaining five years. Not even the deep-pocketed Leafs owners want a buyout on their books for that long.

TORONTO SUN: Terry Koshan reminds us that Rielly’s NMC lasts for two more seasons, after which it becomes a 10-team no-trade list.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: The Leafs will likely carry Rielly for at least two more seasons. They might have to retain part of his salary to facilitate a trade, but carrying some dead-cap space for three years is better than going the buyout route.

PHILLY HOCKEY NOW: William James wonders if the Flyers would make sense as a UFA destination for Marner. While signing the 28-year-old superstar winger would be expensive, James believes he’d be the perfect piece to lift the rebuilding Flyers into playoff contention and lead them into a Stanley Cup hunt in the near future.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: Before debating whether Marner would be a fit with the Flyers, it’s best to ask if they’re a good fit for Marner. He could prefer joining a team that’s closer to contention.

NEW YORK POST: Ethan Sears suggests the Islanders have a window for a double dose of revenge against the Leafs for signing away John Tavares in 2018.

Sears suggested the Isles hire Brendan Shanahan when he becomes available as their new president of hockey operations and/or general manager. He also proposed signing Mitch Marner if the Islanders could find a way to clear some cap space.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: Man, that Tavares signing still burns deep in the psyche of some Islanders’ fans.

Meanwhile, in the real world, the Isles search for a new general manager has reportedly boiled down to former Montreal Canadiens GM Marc Bergevin and Tampa Bay Lightning assistant GM Mathieu Darche.










NHL Rumor Mill – May 19, 2025

NHL Rumor Mill – May 19, 2025

Check out the latest on the Leafs and the Senators in today’s NHL Rumor Mill.

WHAT’S NEXT FOR THE LEAFS?

DAILY FACEOFF: Matt Larkin believes the Toronto Maple Leafs cannot return with the same core next season following another disappointing playoff meltdown.

Larkin doesn’t think Auston Matthews and William Nylander are going anywhere because they’ve just commenced their long-term extension. However, forwards Mitch Marner and John Tavares are eligible to become unrestricted free agents on July 1 and face uncertain futures.

TORONTO SUN: Lance Hornby expects changes among the “Core Four” forwards. He doubts the Leafs will break the bank to keep Marner in Toronto. Meanwhile, Tavares will be 35 when next season starts, and his idea of a hometown discount could differ from management’s.

Toronto Maple Leafs winger Mitch Marner (NHL Images).

Hornby pointed out that winger Matthew Knies is coming off his entry-level contract, becoming a restricted free agent unless he signs an extension before July 1. The 22-year-old power forward could also receive a lucrative offer sheet from a rival club.

THE ATHLETIC: James Mirtle doesn’t see the Leafs retaining team president Brendan Shanahan. After 11 years at the helm, his contract is up at the end of this season.

Mirtle doesn’t expect Marner will be back, pointing out his unwillingness to negotiate a contract during this season and the club’s attempt to move him at the trade deadline. They could retain Tavares at a deep discount, but that might not make sense given he had only three even-strength points in this postseason.

Chris Johnston believes the clock is ticking on Marner’s days with the Leafs. He could become the highest-profile player in this summer’s UFA market. Shouldering a disproportionate share of the blame for the Leafs’ playoff failures could make free agency more alluring to him.

Jonas Siegel sees this as the end of the “Shanaplan” and the “Core Four” era in Toronto.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: We’ve expected changes from Toronto since they blew a 3-1 series lead and lost to the underdog Montreal Canadiens in 2021. This time, however, it feels like significant change is finally coming. They have to. The patience of Leafs Nation is finally tapped out.

Shanahan, Marner and Tavares are on expiring contracts. It’s time for a change in oversight, and it’s time for a shakeup among their core players.

Letting Marner and Tavares walk enables the Leafs to put the dollars they would’ve invested in those two into players who might better suit their needs.

They have a projected cap space of $26.8 million with 16 active roster players (including Matthews, Nylander, and Morgan Rielly) under contract for next season.

That’s enough to make a significant addition or two via trade or free agency and have enough to re-sign Knies to a long-term deal.

THE LATEST ON THE SENATORS

SPORTSNET: Alex Adams was asked about possible offseason targets for the Ottawa Senators.

He thinks pending UFA winger Nikolaj Ehlers of the Winnipeg Jets would be a perfect fit alongside Tim Stutzle. Adding a right-shot defenseman like Florida’s Aaron Ekblad or Rasmus Andersson of the Calgary Flames would be nice, but Adams wondered if they could make a move for a Nick Jensen-type player like Michael Kesselring of the Utah Mammoth.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: The Senators have $17.5 million available with 14 active roster players under contract, with UFA-eligible forward Claude Giroux and pending RFAs Fabian Zetterlund and Tyler Kleven to re-sign. They’ll also need a backup for Linus Ullmark if Anton Forsberg departs via free agency.

Assuming those players are affordable re-signings, the Senators won’t have much wiggle room to pursue guys like Ehlers and Ekblad. Andersson has a year left on his contract but could sign an extension with the Flames this summer. If he becomes available, the Flames will set a high asking price. Kesselring is also under contract for another year. Utah has no reason to move him.

THE ATHLETIC: Julian McKenzie was asked if the Senators might go the offer-sheet route this summer.

McKenzie is keeping his expectations low, pointing out the Senators are keeping their 2025 first-round pick, meaning they’ll forfeit their 2026 pick because of the Evgenii Dadonov trade debacle three years ago. He also pointed out they don’t have their 2026 second-rounder.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: The Senators only have the necessary offer-sheet compensations for deals worth an average annual value of between $1.544 million and $2.34 million. That will cost a 2026 third-rounder. Anything under $1.544 million has no compensation penalty.










Sunday NHL Rumor Roundup – May 18, 2025

Sunday NHL Rumor Roundup – May 18, 2025

Who could the Bruins target with an offer sheet? Should the Flyers attempt to acquire Bowen Byram? What could be in store for the Kings under new GM Ken Holland? Find out in the Sunday NHL Rumor Roundup.

98.5 THE SPORTS HUB: Ty Anderson alphabetically listed seven restricted free agents that he felt the Boston Bruins could target with an offer sheet.

The list includes wingers Will Cuyelle of the New York Rangers, Luke Evangelista of the Nashville Predators, and Kaapo Kakko of the Seattle Kraken, centers Ryan McLeod of the Buffalo Sabres and Mason McTavish of the Anaheim Ducks, winger Dmitri Voronkov of the Columbus Blue Jackets, and Ducks defenseman Drew Helleson.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: Don’t expect the Bruins (or anyone else) to offer up more than $7 million annually to these players listed by Anderson. The compensation for a successful signing between $4.68 million and $7 million is a first and a third-round pick. Anything between $7.020 million and $9.36 million would cost a first, a second, and a third-rounder, plus the risk of overpaying any of those players.

Anaheim Ducks center Mason McTavish (NHL Images)

Scratch McTavish and Helleson from this list. Anaheim has a projected cap space of $36.8 million and can easily match offers for those two.

The same goes for Voronkov, as the Jackets have over $41 million in projected cap space. The 24-year-old winger is with a good group of young players in Columbus and unlikely to consider moving on.

Kakko’s career was rejuvenated after being traded to the Kraken in December. He might not be interested in moving to another club. They have the cap room ($21.7 million) to match.

The Predators have over $17 million in cap room and 21 active roster players under contract for next season. Evangelista has some difficulties this season, but the Preds will be reluctant to part with one of their younger players unless someone overpays to get him.

McLeod could be pried away from the Sabres if they use a big chunk of their $21 million cap space re-signing JJ Peterka and Bowen Byram. However, if they trade Byram, they’ll have plenty of room to match an offer for McLeod.

Cuyelle is the most likely on this list to get an offer sheet if he’s willing to sign one. The Rangers have a projected $8.4 million of cap space with 19 active roster players under contract and defenseman K’Andre Miller is also a restricted free agent. They would have a difficult time matching an offer sheet unless they make a cost-cutting trade before July 1.

PHILLY HOCKEY NOW: William James recently suggested the Flyers should attempt to acquire Bowen Byram from the Buffalo Sabres.

James cited the 24-year-old defenseman’s youth, offensive skills and special team play as factors that would make him a good fit alongside Travis Sanheim on the Flyers’ top defense pairing. He acknowledged Byram’s injury history but felt he’d be worth the risk.

James suggested the Flyers offer up left wing Owen Tippett in return. The 26-year-old is still young, has top-six potential, and has an intriguing skill set. They also have the cap space to take on his $6.2 million average annual value.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: The Flyers need skilled blueline depth while the Sabres seek more offense. If the latter were to trade Byram, they’d likely want an established young scoring forward in return.

Tippett production slipped a bit this season with 20 goals and 43 points, but that could be attributed more to the Flyers’ overall struggles. He reached a career best of 28 goals and 53 points last season. However, they could find his cap hit too expensive for their liking.

THE ATHLETIC: Eric Stephens looked at what might be in store for the Los Angeles Kings under new general manager Ken Holland.

A front-burner issue is whether to re-sign UFA-eligible defenseman Vladislav Gavrikov. In March, former Kings GM Rob Blake expressed confidence in signing Gavrikov to an extension, but that could change under Holland.

Stephens pondered if Holland might make a trade to shake up the roster. He noted that winger Adrian Kempe is a year away from UFA status, Kevin Fiala has a full no-movement clause until July 2026, Phillip Danault has a 10-team no-trade clause, and Trevor Moore lacks no-trade protection.

He also wondered if Holland would consider moving defenseman Drew Doughty. He has two years left on his contract with an AAV of $11 million and must submit a seven-team list of preferred trade destinations.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: It’ll be interesting to see what Holland has in mind for the roster. He could keep the roster intact for the most part to get a better handle on its performance and needs. Gavrikov might be the only significant change if the two sides fail to agree to an extension.










NHL Rumor Mill – May 17, 2025

NHL Rumor Mill – May 17, 2025

Check out the latest on the Wild, Islanders and Red Wings in today’s NHL Rumor Mill.

THE ATHLETIC: Michael Russo and Joe Smith speculated the Minnesota Wild could attempt to land Brock Nelson this summer. The 33-year-old Colorado Avalanche center is eligible for unrestricted free-agent status on July 1.

Smith pointed out that Wild general manager Bill Guerin indicated his priority is to improve his club’s depth at center. They could use a second-line center if Guerin decides to trade Marco Rossi.

Agent Ben Hankinson recently told KFAN that his client (a Minnesota native) was intrigued by the idea of playing at home and he could see a fit. However, Hankinson also expected the Colorado Avalanche will attempt to re-sign Nelson.

Minnesota Wild forward Marco Rossi (NHL Images)

SPECTOR’S NOTE: Other center free-agent options could include Sam Bennett of the Florida Panthers, Matt Duchene of the Dallas Stars, and John Tavares of the Toronto Maple Leafs. However, Nelson could be the Wild’s main target if he goes to market on July 1, depending on what happens with Rossi, who’s coming off his entry-level contract.

THE HOCKEY NEWS: Stefen Rosner believes Minnesota’s Marco Rossi and Winnipeg Jets forward Gabriel Vilardi could be offer-sheet targets for the New York Islanders.

The Islanders are currently searching for a new general manager. Rosner believes that GM could attempt to improve the roster while getting younger, suggesting an offer sheet could be a great way to do it.

Rosner suggested offering Rossi a deal similar to the seven-year contract (with a $6.5 million average annual value) that Matt Coronato recently signed with the Calgary Flames. For Vilardi, it could cost just over $7 million annually on a three to five-year contract.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: That’s assuming either player would entertain offers from rival clubs once they become restricted free agents on July 1.

Rossi could be the more likely candidate, reportedly rejecting an offer from the Wild earlier this season. The oft-injured Vilardi could prefer the stability he enjoys in Winnipeg, but that will also depend on his contract talks with Jets management.

THE ATHLETIC: Max Bultman believes landing a top-four, big-minute defenseman is among the Detroit Red Wings’ priorities to address this offseason. Vladislav Gavrikov of the Los Angeles Kings would be the most intriguing name on the free-agent market.

Bultman was asked if Red Wings general manager Steve Yzerman would consider pitching his first-round pick (13th overall) to acquire prospect Isaac Howard from the Tampa Bay Lightning. He doesn’t think so, suggesting that it would be too much for the Hobey Baker Award winner.

“Howard is still a 5-foot-11 wing who isn’t an explosive skater, “ he wrote, predicting the youngster could become a middle-six NHL winger.










NHL Rumor Mill – May 16, 2025

NHL Rumor Mill – May 16, 2025

How likely is it that Evan Bouchard and Matthew Knies get offer sheets? Who are three possible offer-sheet targets for the Devils? What’s the latest Flyers speculation? Find out in today’s NHL Rumor Mill.

DON’T EXPECT OFFER SHEETS FOR BOUCHARD AND KNIES

THE HOCKEY NEWS: Adam Proteau explains why few high-end restricted free agents, like Edmonton’s Evan Bouchard and Toronto’s Matthew Knies, receive offer sheets.

Those players are crucial to their team’s future, and opposing teams don’t often have the combinations of salary-cap space and compensatory draft picks.

Edmonton Oilers defenseman Evan Bouchard (NHL Images).

Proteau points out that a team would have to surrender two first-round picks, a second-rounder, and a third-rounder if they successfully sign Bouchard or Knies to an offer sheet with an average annual value between $9.36 million and $11.7 million.

Teams offering either player a deal between $7 million and $9.36 million annually would have to pony up a first-round pick, a second-rounder, and a third-rounder.

Proteau contrasted those with what it cost the St. Louis Blues to sign away Philip Broberg and Dylan Holloway from the Oilers last August. The Blues gave up a second-rounder as compensation for Broberg and a third-rounder for Holloway.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: The Blues wouldn’t have gotten Broberg or Holloway if they’d offered a second or a third-rounder in a trade pitch. It was an affordable move by St. Louis general manager Doug Armstrong to sign up two promising young players with bright futures with their new club.

Those are the type of offer-sheet signings we’re more likely to see. Teams will zero in on cap-strapped clubs with promising talent that they can sign to cost-effective contracts without giving up much in compensation.

We can’t fully dismiss the possibility of Bouchard or Knies signing an offer sheet. It’s just hard to see which team would have the necessary cap space and the appropriate number of their own draft picks to make it happen.

THREE PROPOSED OFFER-SHEET TARGETS FOR THE DEVILS

NEW JERSEY HOCKEY NOW: James Nichols proposed three bold offer-sheet targets for the Devils if they want to build up their roster aggressively this summer.

Nichols suggests forward JJ Peterka of the Buffalo Sabres, Marco Rossi of the Minnesota Wild, and Mason McTavish of the Anaheim Ducks.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: The Sabres, Wild and Ducks all possess sufficient cap space to match any offer sheet for those players.

Doing so could still create a salary-cap headache for the Sabres and Wild, but they could work around it with a cost-cutting trade.

Meanwhile, the Ducks have over $38 million in projected cap space. Even if they don’t spend to the cap, they have plenty to match an offer for McTavish and still have enough to re-sign or add key players.

LATEST ON THE FLYERS

THE ATHLETIC: Earlier this week, Kevin Kurz was asked which player he thinks the Flyers might pursue if they were offered up their first-round pick (sixth overall) in this year’s draft. He rules out Anaheim’s Mason McTavish as he’s crucial for the Ducks’ playoff hopes next season. Kurz suggested Seattle’s Matty Beniers, Dallas’ Wyatt Johnston, or San Jose’s Will Smith.

SPECTOR’S NOTE: They would all be worthwhile targets if the Flyers were willing to dangle their first-rounder. However, it’s unlikely any of them would be available.

Kurz was also asked which Flyers winger might become trade bait if management goes shopping for a center this summer. He suggested Bobby Brink, whose stock should be rising after his 41-point performance this season.